montehawks's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[old_piano_man]

This kept my attention throughout the entire track, and that's rarely accomplished on NG. Props to you sir. Very well mastered, very well put together.

Only critiques would be:
1. The piano intro makes the song sound childish up until the dub... You could have made the track sound a lot cooler up until that point.
2. Some very strange sounds mixed in with the dub that didn't quite go with the overall flow.

Otherwise brilliant.

Squarion responds:

Thanks see i normally make trance so im kinda noob at dubstep/glitch hop. very much appreciated

[Ravign - Happy Dubstep]

Not a bad first song by any means, the clipping is definitely an issue however. If it was mastered correctly I feel it'd be something worth having at the top of the charts.

PS: Scouted ya, you should be good to go to submit more work. Good luck and welcome to (the audio portion of) NG! :)

Cyrman responds:

Thank you, I know about the issues, I'm looking into remastering this actually. If you want to, go ahead :)

[Lone X - Remember]

From a fellow dubstep artist, respect.

Great work son.

Lone-X responds:

I really appreciate that, thanks man!

Peace and love,
Lone X

[Xenophobic]

It's pretty neat actually,

The beginning arp is a good way to start the song for sure. Perhaps try applying a filter or stronger filter to it to give it some variance.

1:20 - The synth popping in now and again adds further flavour to the piece. Very well written.

1:34 - The completes the song in my opinion. It definitely gives it the video game feel. However, at 1:47, the notes are severely out of tune. They're out of tune again at 2:07. And at progressively different parts of the song as well. Whatever notes being used at those times either aren't apart of the scale youre writing in, or they're chorded wrong.

Overall - pretty decent track :) Just gotta work out a few kinks here and there and you'll be good to go. I can definitely picture this in some type of arcade game!

Neon-Bard responds:

First off I would like to say, thank you for the review. :)

I really appreciate it when I get important feedback like this. Listening to 1:47 now makes me cringe a little, I'm really glad you pointed that out. I must have had my head in the clouds when I recorded those notes. :P I think part of it came from the fact that I was trying to allow room for an upper octave there, and well, the result was this.

Once again, thanks for the comments, I'll improve the song and hopefully it will turn out better than the original.

[Release The Demons: Tainted]

God that buildup at the beginning..

Sent me on a mad search of where I heard that before.

Then I found it, nearly at the end of the list of premade songs in FL's "Cool Stuff" folder. Fall Silently by Toby Emerson and Christoph Maitland Featuring Veela. So the buildups aren't yours, and bass sound that chimes in at 00:10, 00:18, 00:25, and so on is not yours. The melody the synth at 1:32 plays is also not yours as it's copying the base from the original song about 95% correctly. So I minus points for originality.

But I give you points on attempting to make this into some type of dubstep song, mostly because I'm learning the genre myself, and it's a tough one to learn. Usually dubstep beats are half as fast as trance beats, so when you want to make a transition to wobbles, try changing up the beat.

All in all, this song isn't very original, but it's not half bad. However it needs a major overhaul. :) Good luck to you on your future music, I know you can create something great, now get to it!

7/10

demonrunner23 responds:

lol yea i got fl from scratch n just remixed Fall Silently by Toby Emerson and Christoph Maitland Featuring Veela in a few minutes n i kinda liked it.

[Neon Black V 0.1]

Holy smokes there's a lot going on in this song,

The volume is clipping like a mo-fo, the guitar was incredibly off key, and the drums are really repetitive.

Oh god, more guitar (00:40)

I'll admit the only reason I clicked on this song was because it had the word "Neon" in it, and I used to own one of those. Haha.

Please don't try and sell this. But rather work to make it into something great. :) I know you must have the talent somewhere!

acrios90 responds:

Thanks For the Review.
Do you think Changing the guitar to another Instrument that is less powering will help. (And maybe revising the notes a bit? I am still a beginner and I am up for any advise!

[Secret Valentine (Cover)]

I love piano,

And what you did here, sir, is brilliant. When the guitar and drums kicked in that brought the song to a whole new level. This is really good. Perhaps a bit too simplistic for my tastes (but maybe that's because there's no vocals). Everything about this piece is written perfectly, it's way too often I catch off-key note after off-key note is some peoples music... and that just sends my ears screaming for the hills. The only off key note I noticed in this song was at 2:27. Whatever that note is, it just isn't working, haha.

I strongly suggest getting some vocals for this, if you ever do contact me so I can DL and fav the song!

Cheers!

PS: I love the outro to this song as well. Great job man.

bigbeek responds:

I know this is extremely laaaaate hahahah x) but thanks for the review I actually did finish this tune I just never uploaded If you do want a final copy just PM a message and i'll shoot you a mediafire link to the final!

[Pull Your Strap]

I was about to criticize your use of caps lock,

But then at :22 the song got catchy enough to divert my attention. This actually isn't too bad. I'm not the biggest fan of rap, but I love all music because I know what it takes to make a track. Hours and hours of hard work, often to end up revamping a project from the start when it was about half way done.

10/10
5/5

Good luck out there man, you have talent!

legaceymusic responds:

THANK YOU SO MUCH THAT MEANS SO MUCH TO ME. IM TRYING HARD
LEGACEYBEATS.COM

CHECK THIS OUT

http://soundcloud.com/legaceyb/the-ge t-up

[A New World Loop]

Oh that sure does sound fancy,

I scrolled down to write a review on how good this is.. Then it ended. Then I was about to say how you should make this into a full song. Then I noticed it's already a full song.

Now I'm wondering why you submitted part of a song that's already completed.

DarkShadow166 responds:

Haha.

Well I submitted it in case anyone wants to use it as a loop. It's a little different from the original too (the drums are different, there's a harp, some background notes are different, etc...) and basically I didn't want it to stay gathering binary dust in my hard disk.

Thanks for the review! And for calling it fancy, of course :D.

[Innocent Deception]

I'm literally in awe...

Of how amazing this track is. You have done an INCREDIBLE job. What caught my ear the most was the skill in writing the notes themselves, it's as if I was wanting the next note because I knew it was going to be good. And each time you did not disappoint. Just wow, this is great. The piano in the beginning was probably my favorite part, I love good intros. Then the guitar immediately following was perfect.

I'm now hitting the part that introduces the saxophone. That is incredible. I love the classical feel of songs and this has every element just perfect. Not to mention, Claire's voice is flawless.

You've done this game an honor, this track is incredible in every way shape and form.

5/5
10/10
Fav

DjMystix responds:

Thanks a lot for the kind words! We really put our heart and soul in making this track. After, MGS is my most favorite games of all time :D

Glad you enjoyed the track!